| Year | Wine | Variety | Location | Num |
| | Americana Vineyards Barn Raising Red | Cawtaba and Baco Noir blend | Top Shelf | 1 |
| | Americana Vineyards Crystal Lake | Niagara | Middle Shelf | 1 |
| | Ashley Lynn Winery Apple Cherry | Fruit Wine: Apple | Bottom shelf | 1 |
| 2006 | Bodegas Concavins Proyecto Cu4tro Blanco | White Blend | Middle Shelf | 1 |
| 2006 | Brutocao Cellars Estate Bottled Bliss Vineyards Classic Chardonnay | Chardonnay | Middle Shelf | 1 |
| | Cayuga Ridge Estate Late Harvest Solo | Ice Wine | Bottom shelf | 1 |
| 2006 | Chapel Hill | Shiraz | Top Shelf | 1 |
| 2005 | Château de Cruzeau | Red Bordeaux Blend | Top Shelf | 1 |
| 2006 | Congress Springs | Viognier | Middle Shelf | 1 |
| 2006 | Coyote Creek | Chardonnay | Middle Shelf | 1 |
| 2006 | Fess Parker Select Cuvée | Chardonnay | Middle Shelf | 1 |
| | Four Chimneys Organic Winery Blueberry Skies | Dessert Wine | Bottom shelf | 1 |
| | Fratelli Desiato Vineyards Caspita | Red Wine | Top Shelf | 2 |
| | Fratelli Desiato Vineyards Dolce Vita Reserve | Fredonia | Top Shelf | 1 |
| | Fratelli Desiato Vineyards Punch di San Giorgio | Spiced grape wine w/ citrus & herb | Bottom shelf | 1 |
| | Fratelli Desiato Vineyards Purple Piglet Sangria Italiana | Fruit Wine | Top Shelf | 1 |
| | Heritage Wine Cellars Bursting Blueberry | Sparkling Wine | Bottom shelf | 2 |
| 2005 | Hooper's Hall California Merlot | Merlot | Top Shelf | 1 |
| 2007 | Initial Estates Montgomery Estate | Chardonnay | Middle Shelf | 1 |
| | Long Trout Winery Azure Blue | Fruit Wine: Blueberry | Bottom shelf | 1 |
| 2003 | Long Trout Winery Dark and Disturbing | Steuben | Top Shelf | 1 |
| | Long Trout Winery Flower Power | Cabernet | Top Shelf | 1 |
| | Long Trout Winery Instant "O" | Fruit Wine: Chocolate Strawberry | Bottom shelf | 2 |
| | Long Trout Winery Light My Fire | Fruit Wine: Pepper & Raisin blend | Bottom shelf | 2 |
| | Long Trout Winery Lus-T-berry | White Wine w/ Teaberry Flavor | Middle Shelf | 1 |
| | Long Trout Winery Psychedelic Jack O' Lantern | Fruit Wine: Spiced Pumpkin | Bottom shelf | 1 |
| | Long Trout Winery Rusty Roots | Fruit Wine: Sweet Potato | Bottom shelf | 2 |
| 2003 | Lucas & Lewellen Vineyards Mandolina Toccata "Riserva" | Super Tuscan | Top Shelf | 1 |
| | Maiolatesi Wine Cellars Cranberry Cayuga White | Sparkling Wine | | |
| | Maiolatesi Wine Cellars Strawberry Cayuga White | Cayuga | Middle Shelf | 1 |
| | Montezuma Winery Cranberry Bog | Fruit Wine: Cranberry | Bottom shelf | 1 |
| | Newport Vineyards BAC (Gemini Red) | Red Wine | Top Shelf | 1 |
| | Peace Valley Chalfont Rouge | Rose | | |
| 2005 | Quail Hollow Wordly Flight Merlot | Merlot | Top Shelf | 1 |
| 2005 | Rock Hollow Vintner's Selection | Merlot | Top Shelf | 1 |
| | Sand Castle Winery Alpine Spice | Spiced Chardonnay/Riesling blend | Bottom shelf | 3 |
| | Six Mile Creek Vineyard Pasa Tiempo | White Wine | Middle Shelf | 1 |
| | Sorrenti's Cherry Valley Vineyards Cranberry Blush | Fruit Wine: Cranberry | Bottom shelf | 1 |
| 2006 | Tarrica Wine Cellars Limited Release | Petite Sirah | Top Shelf | 1 |
| 2006 | Thirsty Owl Wine Company Snow Owl | White Wine | | 0 |
| 2007 | Willow Springs | Sauvignon Blanc | Middle Shelf | 1 |